Tulip Podcast Manager 🎙️ Bojana Lalic

Recording a podcast episode with a guest is an exciting opportunity to bring fresh perspectives and new voices to your show. But sometimes, despite your best efforts, things don’t go as planned. Maybe the episode didn’t turn out the way you expected, or perhaps the conversation didn’t align with your podcast’s theme. Whatever the reason, you may find yourself in the position of having a recorded podcast episode with a guest that you decide not to publish.

So, what do you do when you’ve recorded a guest episode but choose not to release it?

In this blog post, we’ll explore the best ways to handle an episode you no longer want to publish, while maintaining professionalism and preserving relationships with your guest.

Evaluate the Reason for Not Publishing

Why It Matters

Before making any decisions, it’s important to evaluate the specific reason why you’re considering not publishing the episode. Understanding the root cause can help you determine the best course of action moving forward.

How to Do It

Is the content off-brand? If the episode doesn’t align with your podcast’s theme or goals, it may be worth reconsidering whether to release it. However, don’t be afraid to repurpose the content in the future when it fits your overall strategy.

Audio or technical issues? Poor sound quality or other technical issues can be frustrating, but they’re often fixable. Try to edit the episode and clean up any noise or glitches before making a final decision.

Guest performance concerns? If the guest wasn’t a good fit or didn’t speak as clearly as you hoped, it’s worth discussing whether the episode can be salvaged through editing.

Once you understand why you don’t want to publish the episode, you’ll be in a better position to decide whether to publish at all, make edits, or simply scrap it altogether.

Communicate with Your Guest

Why It Matters

It’s essential to maintain open communication with your guest, especially if you’ve already recorded an episode with them. Being transparent and respectful ensures that you keep a positive relationship and avoid misunderstandings.

How to Do It

Be honest but tactful: Explain to your guest why the episode isn’t a good fit for your podcast. Whether it’s due to technical issues, content misalignment, or any other reason, honesty is key. Make sure to express your appreciation for their time and insights during the recording session.

Offer alternatives: If you feel the conversation wasn’t ideal for your podcast but still valuable, offer alternatives. For example, you could invite them back for another episode or suggest that they share their insights in a different format (such as a guest blog post or social media collaboration).

Thank them for their time: Regardless of whether the episode will be published, thank your guest for their time and participation. Offering a positive experience for your guests will keep the door open for future collaborations.

Consider Editing or Repurposing the Episode

Why It Matters

In many cases, you may be able to salvage the episode and make it work for your podcast. Even if the conversation didn’t go perfectly, editing or repurposing the content can help create a more polished final product.

How to Do It

Edit for clarity and relevance: If the episode contains valuable insights but didn’t meet your expectations, editing can make a big difference. Remove unnecessary sections, cut out long pauses or tangents, and focus on the key points that your audience will find valuable.

Repurpose for other content: If the episode doesn’t fit your podcast, think about repurposing it into something else. For example, you could turn interesting quotes into social media content, create a blog post summarizing the key takeaways, or use the material for future episodes when the content aligns better.
Editing or repurposing content allows you to still make the most out of your hard work while maintaining your podcast’s overall direction.

Consider the Impact on Your Podcast’s Brand

Why It Matters

Every episode you publish contributes to your podcast’s overall brand and message. If you’re considering not releasing an episode, think about how it may impact your podcast’s public image and audience perception.

How to Do It

Maintain your integrity: If the episode doesn’t align with your values or the direction you want for your podcast, it’s okay to decide not to publish it. However, make sure to handle the situation respectfully and professionally, especially when working with guests.
Avoid overthinking it: While it’s important to maintain a consistent brand, don’t overthink every decision. Sometimes, things just don’t work out, and that’s okay. Learn from the experience and use it to guide future recordings and guest invitations.

How to Prevent This Situation in the Future

Why It Matters

One episode that you decide not to release doesn’t have to be a recurring issue. By implementing a few preventive steps, you can reduce the likelihood of this happening again and ensure smoother episodes moving forward.

How to Do It

Screen guests carefully: Be clear about your podcast’s mission and audience expectations before inviting guests. This will help ensure they are aligned with your podcast’s goals and tone.

Prepare better: Take extra time to prepare for interviews, creating a list of questions, topics to cover, and expectations for the conversation. This will help prevent miscommunications and increase the chances of a productive episode.

Test your equipment: Check your recording setup in advance to minimize technical problems. Conduct a quick test run before you start recording to make sure everything is working as it should.

---

Deciding not to publish a podcast episode with a guest can be a tough decision, but it doesn’t have to be a negative experience. By communicating openly with your guest, exploring editing options, and learning from the situation, you can handle this scenario with professionalism and grace. Remember, your podcast is a reflection of your brand, so always prioritize content that aligns with your values and resonates with your audience.

Whether you decide to publish the episode, repurpose it, or simply move on, the key is to learn and grow from the experience to ensure future podcasting success.